Let’s get our tragedy causation straight…

“Our family is dead because they lied to us…” – Family member of a miner who died in the Sago, WV explosion [MSNBC, 1/4/06]

Umm, no. Your family is dead because they were in a mine two miles underground during a very large methane explosion. I understand tragedy can be very disorienting and confusing. And yes, the communications about these guys was terribly botched. But, the botching of the communications did not kill these guys. And no sane human thinks this was lying. Stupidity, yes – but not lying. And, that stupidity is not to blame for their deaths. Perhaps the saddest part is the irony that it was apparently family members themselves who initially started spreading the word that they were alive.

It’s also extremely angering that the media would perpetuate all of this last night when these reports were totally unconfirmed. Not a single official had gone on record to say these guys were OK. Yet it ran in dozens of newspapers this morning and all over the web.

This is an unfortunate and painful illustration of that old adage, “a lie is halfway around the world before the truth even gets its pants on.”

5 thoughts on “Let’s get our tragedy causation straight…”

  1. Ding Dong! Hello? Anybody home? I’ve made a few mistakes in my day and blamed the wrong person, but this isn’t even close! Wow.

    I feel for these poor people and I can’t begin to imagine what they are going through with this tragedy, but come on… seriously now… could they really see the coroner’s report listing the Cause of Death as “Miscommunication”. Okay.

  2. Ding Dong! Hello? Anybody home? I’ve made a few mistakes in my day and blamed the wrong person, but this isn’t even close! Wow.

    I feel for these poor people and I can’t begin to imagine what they are going through with this tragedy, but come on… seriously now… could they really see the coroner’s report listing the Cause of Death as “Miscommunication”. Okay.

  3. Let’s get back to blaming who’s really at fault for everything–the big guy: God. Oh no wait, or is he going to get us through this? Shit, I’m confused.

  4. Let’s get back to blaming who’s really at fault for everything–the big guy: God. Oh no wait, or is he going to get us through this? Shit, I’m confused.

  5. Look dammnit, leave god out of this. The only person responsible was obviously that fat burglaring bastard, Mr. Kringle himself. Let’s not let that jerk off the hook.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.